RAC环境redo在各节点本地导致数据库故障恢复

最近一个运行在win平台的rac,由于断电之后,集群两个节点均无法正常启动,客户进行了一系列尝试,结果到了ora-600 kclchkblk_4错误无法继续.
通过对数据库日志分析,回溯了故障大概的原因,启动的时候报错为:
节点1启动报错

Sun Aug 03 15:21:22 2025
alter database open
This instance was first to open
Beginning crash recovery of 2 threads
 parallel recovery started with 32 processes
Started redo scan
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_ora_7108.trc:
ORA-00314: 日志 11 (用于线程 2) 要求的 sequence# 147717 与 147541 不匹配
ORA-00312: 联机日志 11 线程 2: 'D:\REDOLOG\REDO011.LOG'
Abort recovery for domain 0
Aborting crash recovery due to error 314
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_ora_7108.trc:
ORA-00314: 日志 11 (用于线程 2) 要求的 sequence# 147717 与 147541 不匹配
ORA-00312: 联机日志 11 线程 2: 'D:\REDOLOG\REDO011.LOG'
Abort recovery for domain 0
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_ora_7108.trc:
ORA-00314: 日志 11 (用于线程 2) 要求的 sequence# 147717 与 147541 不匹配
ORA-00312: 联机日志 11 线程 2: 'D:\REDOLOG\REDO011.LOG'
ORA-314 signalled during: alter database open...

节点2启动报错

Sat Aug 02 15:45:43 2025
Successful mount of redo thread 2, with mount id 1735887907
Database mounted in Shared Mode (CLUSTER_DATABASE=TRUE)
Lost write protection disabled
Completed: ALTER DATABASE MOUNT /* db agent *//* {1:47460:124} */
ALTER DATABASE OPEN /* db agent *//* {1:47460:124} */
This instance was first to open
Beginning crash recovery of 2 threads
Sat Aug 02 15:45:49 2025
 parallel recovery started with 32 processes
Started redo scan
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl2\trace\orcl2_ora_3444.trc:
ORA-00314: ?? 1 (???? 1) ??? sequence# 67782 ? 60818 ???
ORA-00312: ???? 1 ?? 1: 'D:\REDOLOG\REDO01.LOG'
Abort recovery for domain 0
Aborting crash recovery due to error 314
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl2\trace\orcl2_ora_3444.trc:
ORA-00314: ?? 1 (???? 1) ??? sequence# 67782 ? 60818 ???
ORA-00312: ???? 1 ?? 1: 'D:\REDOLOG\REDO01.LOG'
Abort recovery for domain 0
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl2\trace\orcl2_ora_3444.trc:
ORA-00314: ?? 1 (???? 1) ??? sequence# 67782 ? 60818 ???
ORA-00312: ???? 1 ?? 1: 'D:\REDOLOG\REDO01.LOG'
ORA-314 signalled during: ALTER DATABASE OPEN /* db agent *//* {1:47460:124} */...

看到这两个报错信息得出两个结论：
1）比较明显节点1需要thead 2的 group 11 sequence为147717,但是实际group 11文件的sequence为147541；而节点2启动需要thread 1的group 1 sequence为67782，但是实际中group 1文件的sequnece为60818,这两个都相差比较多,属于非正常的情况,很可能是文件本身有问题
2）这是一套win的rac架构,理论上redo应该在共享文件系统（一般是asm中)，而这个第一感觉很可能是本地文件系统中
客户当时恢复之时查询信息截图

查看了两个节点的最后redo切换信息

--节点1
Sat Aug 02 10:49:31 2025
Thread 1 advanced to log sequence 67782 (LGWR switch)
  Current log# 1 seq# 67782 mem# 0: D:\REDOLOG\REDO01.LOG

--节点2（redo每组2G,节点2长时间没跑业务,之时做数据库导出操作,所以切换时间比较久远）
Sat Jul 26 16:56:42 2025
Thread 2 advanced to log sequence 147717 (LGWR switch)
  Current log# 11 seq# 147717 mem# 0: D:\REDOLOG\REDO011.LOG

并查看两个机器d:/redolog信息(客户自行resetlogs之后的,非第一现场,但是可以确认两个节点各自有一份redo文件

本来这个是一个比较小的故障,只要把节点2的thread 1的redo拷贝到到节点1或者节点1的thread 2的redo拷贝到节点2,然后正常open库即可,现场恢复对rac不太熟悉,直接按照互联网上检索的处理方法,加上_allow_resetlogs_corruption然后强制拉库,结果不太幸运,拉库失败报ORA-600 kclchkblk_4错误

Sun Aug 03 18:59:24 2025
alter database open resetlogs
RESETLOGS is being done without consistancy checks. This may result
in a corrupted database. The database should be recreated.
RESETLOGS after incomplete recovery UNTIL CHANGE 21497084214
Resetting resetlogs activation ID 1543012633 (0x5bf88119)
Sun Aug 03 18:59:46 2025
Setting recovery target incarnation to 3
Sun Aug 03 18:59:46 2025
This instance was first to open
Picked broadcast on commit scheme to generate SCNs
Sun Aug 03 18:59:48 2025
Assigning activation ID 1735960667 (0x6778a85b)
Thread 1 opened at log sequence 1
  Current log# 1 seq# 1 mem# 0: D:\REDOLOG\REDO01.LOG
Successful open of redo thread 1
MTTR advisory is disabled because FAST_START_MTTR_TARGET is not set
Sun Aug 03 18:59:49 2025
SMON: enabling cache recovery
Instance recovery: looking for dead threads
Instance recovery: lock domain invalid but no dead threads
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_ora_8508.trc  (incident=728324):
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [kclchkblk_4], [5], [200595988], [5], [22247740], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Incident details in: D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\incident\incdir_728324\orcl1_ora_8508_i728324.trc
Use ADRCI or Support Workbench to package the incident.
See Note 411.1 at My Oracle Support for error and packaging details.
Sun Aug 03 18:59:53 2025
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_ora_8508.trc:
ORA-00704: 引导程序进程失败
ORA-00704: 引导程序进程失败
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [kclchkblk_4], [5], [200595988], [5], [22247740], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_ora_8508.trc:
ORA-00704: 引导程序进程失败
ORA-00704: 引导程序进程失败
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [kclchkblk_4], [5], [200595988], [5], [22247740], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Error 704 happened during db open, shutting down database
USER (ospid: 8508): terminating the instance due to error 704
Sun Aug 03 18:59:54 2025
opiodr aborting process unknown ospid (9480) as a result of ORA-1092
Sun Aug 03 19:00:09 2025
Instance terminated by USER, pid = 8508
ORA-1092 signalled during: alter database open resetlogs...
opiodr aborting process unknown ospid (8508) as a result of ORA-1092

这个故障之后,客户那边无法自行恢复,让我这边介入处理,对于这个错误以前处理比较多,一般就是scn问题,通过Patch SCN小工具快速解决

数据库open成功之后主要报一些ORA-600 4137,ORA-600 6006等错误

Database Characterset is ZHS16GBK
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_smon_8300.trc  (incident=1176205):
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [4137], [1.14.2713957], [0], [0], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Incident details in: D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\incident\incdir_1176205\orcl1_smon_8300_i1176205.trc
Use ADRCI or Support Workbench to package the incident.
See Note 411.1 at My Oracle Support for error and packaging details.
Fri Aug 08 19:03:14 2025
ORACLE Instance orcl1 (pid = 25) - Error 600 encountered while recovering transaction (1, 14).
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_smon_8300.trc:
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [4137], [1.14.2713957], [0], [0], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Fri Aug 08 19:03:15 2025
ORACLE Instance orcl1 (pid = 25) - Error 600 encountered while recovering transaction (5, 19).
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_smon_8300.trc:
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [4137], [5.19.2318502], [0], [0], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Starting background process MMON
Fri Aug 08 19:03:18 2025
MMON started with pid=29, OS id=4624
Fri Aug 08 19:03:19 2025
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_smon_8300.trc  (incident=1176207):
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [6006], [1], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], []
Incident details in: D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\incident\incdir_1176207\orcl1_smon_8300_i1176207.trc
Starting background process MMNL
Fri Aug 08 19:03:19 2025
MMNL started with pid=30, OS id=8344
Use ADRCI or Support Workbench to package the incident.
See Note 411.1 at My Oracle Support for error and packaging details.
ORACLE Instance orcl1 (pid = 25) - Error 600 encountered while recovering transaction (46, 28) on object 197344.
Errors in file D:\APP\ADMINISTRATOR\diag\rdbms\orcl\orcl1\trace\orcl1_smon_8300.trc:
ORA-00600: 内部错误代码, 参数: [6006], [1], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], [], []

通过重建undo解决该错误,数据库稳定运行,没有再crash和报明显错误,导出核心数据,完成本次恢复任务.